Zeppelin versus not Zeppelin
Jun. 3rd, 2010 08:59 pm| Zeppelin Free | Zeppelin Heavy |
|---|---|
| The Oxford Book of Modern Scientific Writing | The Osiris Ritual |
| A Mathematician's Apology | The Court of the Air |
| The Rapture | Transition |
| The City & The City | Half a Crown |
| Antimatter | The Kindom Beyond the Waves |
| Freakonomics | Terminal World |
| Why Evolution is True | The Rise of the Iron Moon |
| Dust | Feersum Endjinn |
| The Black Ship | Retribution Falls |
| The Girl With Glass Feet | Seeds of Earth |
| The Elegant Universe | The Orphaned Worlds |
| A Murder of Quality | Ghosts of Manhattan |
| Chill | |
| Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy | |
| The Little Stranger | |
| Smiley's People | |
| The Secret Pilgrim | |
| The Ambassador's Mission | |
| The Age of Absurdity | |
| Yellow Blue Tibia | |
| Tithe | |
| White Noise | |
| Falling Man | |
| Hammered | |
| Mezzanine |
I have been generous with my criteria for the with-zeppelins group, counting anything that features any form of lighter-than-air aircraft regardless of the duration of its appearance. In most cases, there can be little controversy; most of the books in the zeppelins category contain them in their numbers.
But there are two borderline cases. Firstly, Half a Crown, which features a fleeting reference to Hitler's arriving in Britain aboard an airship; a small thing, but definitely enough to count. Secondly and more dubiously, Transition, which doesn't feature any airships that I recall, but does feature a moment in which the main character looks up to see if there are any zeppelins passing overhead; this is definitely borderline and probably only included to allow Banks to point out the tired old trope of including airships simply to indicate that the book has entered alternate history territory, but this also implies that there could be airships even though there are aren't, and on those grounds I'm including it in the with-zeppelins category.